A weapon to surpass Metal Gear
Published on , 3579 words, 14 minutes to read
Every so often, I like to look at some of the more weird conspiracy theories and then try to debunk them. I consider it a media literacy exercise, but there has been one theory that I've come across that is impressively hard to debunk: the "Dead Internet" theory. I think that the best conspiracy theories are the ones that are hardest to debunk, and this one is increasingly getting more difficult to debunk.
The core idea is that the Internet itself is actually dead, no human authorship of any content exists. Any actual human content that is created is isolated into its own little heavenbanned bubble. Mainstream platforms, news outlets, social media sites, Internet forums, chatrooms, everything filled with bot generated content to the point that it's impossible to find another human. The same arguments cycle back and forth throughout the forums with new dramatis personae every iteration.
To be clear, this theory as literally written is absolute nonsense and probably not worth taking too seriously. A lot of this theory was originally designed to come up with reasons why people in forums will just randomly vanish forever, never to be seen or heard from again. That friend that you played Team Fortress 2 with for years? Ten years offline on Steam. No goodbyes. No warning they'd leave. They just vanish.
As someone who has experienced this type of vanishing a lot, I get where the conspiracy theory comes from. I think it's quite a stretch to assert that it's the result of chatbots, or something. But over all this is a very interesting thing to try to dissect and argue against. As AI models get more complicated and their output gets more and more convincing, it's getting difficult to impossible to actually argue against this theory.
This is something that is entirely possible to create with the modern technology we have.
I hope that this is actually a false assertion, but it's getting difficult to make the case that it is. This has really given me a lot of pause and started to make me wonder what this technology is actually going to be end up used for.
As a writer, there's two ways that you can analyze futurism and science fiction. The common model is to compare it to the car. If you are to talk about the idea of the car, the possibilities it allows for, and what it enables people to do, that is futurism. Futurism is mainly talking about the ideas and thoughts about what technology could give us. For comparison, if you were to analyze it as science fiction, you would probably start with the idea of traffic jams. Futurism would enable people to live and work in different geographical places, this is something that has not commonly been done for the vast majority of history for the vast majority of population. People generally lived where they worked, because travel was difficult, expensive, and annoying. But, if everyone has to do that, then there will likely be times where the roads are filled with cars for people trying to get to somewhere else so they can do their job. This creates a traffic jam. This is the science fiction of the car.
I would like to wager that AI technologies like ChatGPT, Stable Diffusion, LLaMA, Whisper, and more are looked at in the eyes of futurism. To contrast, I believe the "dead internet" theory is the science fiction. If we have the ability to create all of this stuff automatically by machine, then what will be left for humans to enjoy?
Metrics and Ratios
At some level though, I recognize that for about eighty percent of the articles that people actually read, an AI generated article is probably sufficient. Consider the fact that most of articles that people read are very basic high level things:
- X died
- X person said Y
- Event happened at place
- "No Way To Prevent This," Says Only Nation Where This Regularly Happens
Statistically, most people won't even read past the title anyways. This is why titles get clickbaited. Because people want you to read the fucking article, and nobody reads past the title. Consider the fact that when Elon Musk, one of the biggest accounts on Twitter, tweeted a link to someone's webpage, there was a less than one percent click through rate. When you don't click on a link on Twitter, all you see is the title and any extra preview data that Twitter scraped.
If that has a less than one percent click through rate, then why should companies bother to pay humans to write articles that aren't going to be read?
Turns out, capitalism has noticed this. Buzzfeed is reportedly using AI models to generate its listicles and other filler content. CNET also recently had a spat with AI generated articles, albeit one that ended poorly.
Arsène
What could such a dead internet look like? I decided to do a little experiment and find out. I call the results Arsène. It is a little app with Deno and Fresh that creates a new article about every 12 hours about the current phase of the moon, astrological sign, and three tarot cards to describe the past, present, and future. It feeds all of this into ChatGPT and I have done very little prompt engineering to try and hide the fact that it is AI generated.
My fear is that all major/popular websites will end up looking like this. Pleasing design, modern user experience, but absolutely nothing worth witnessing.
If there's going to be all of this automatically generated content, how are we going to sort through it all? Who is going to take the time to curate things? How will information search change in the wake of this technology?
Context
Metal Gear is a series of games made by producer Hideo Kojima. The series has always covered complicated topics such as war, political philosophy, existentialism, free will, understanding how ideology spreads, and in general is seen as the precursor to understanding a lot of how the US has developed. And you get to play as super-solders trying to piece together everything as it all burns.
This series is well worth playing, or at the very least watching the cutscenes on YouTube. One of the most important things that it covers is the idea of free will, and censorship on the internet. At some level, its thesis is that America is diseased. Rotten to the core. We drown ourselves in information, and there is no good way to sort it, analyze it, or know what's worth preserving and what's worth discarding.
In Metal Gear Solid 2, there is a faction known as "The Patriots". They are a group of artificial intelligence models that has slowly built up and gained sapience in the White House. By the events of Metal Gear Solid 2, the patriots control the entire country. The president is the puppet of the patriots. Information is censored through the patriots. Broadcast TV, internet forums, email, chatrooms, all of it censored by the patriots. Oh, and they control the nuclear launch codes.
There is one cut seen at the end of the game where the patriots spell out their core thesis and their rationale for why they are doing what they are doing. I'm going to be quoting parts of it as I continue this article, but you should really watch the entire thing to help you understand where I'm coming from here:
Even without the help of artificial intelligence models, we create so much information that there is no way that anyone is going to be able to sort through it. In ten seconds, something ridiculous like eighty five hours of video is uploaded to YouTube. Untold terabytes of data are minted at Twitter. Millions of blogs post billions of articles every day. There is so much information, and so much noise, that even the one company that was designed to sort through the internet is having difficulty sorting through the internet.
And now, it is even easier to continue that 24/7 spew of trivia and celebrity bullshit with things like large language models. As an example, let's think about that art project that I linked to earlier. Here is the verbatim prompt that it uses in order to generate articles:
const prompt = `Ethereum is worth ${ethUSD} US dollars.
The current lunar phase is ${lunarPhase}.
The current astrological sign is ${astrologicalSign()}.
The current date is ${new Date().toDateString()}.
Past events: ${tarotReading[0].fortune_telling[0]}
Current events: ${tarotReading[1].fortune_telling[0]}
Prediction: ${tarotReading[2].fortune_telling[0]}
Write a lengthy analysis article that speculates why the prediction will come to pass and what it will do to the price of Ethereum. Lead your analysis with a line containing an original title followed by two new lines.`;
Consider this: that project was made in literally two days as an exploration of how this technology could lead to a "dead internet". I made this because of a quote that my mentor gave me:
Come on now, put your fears on the canvas and then you can see how bad they really are. It's easy to get caught up in the imagined fears of hypotheticals, but looking your fear right at the face lets you see if it's truly something to be afraid of.
So I did that. Just imagine, I did this in two days as a joke. If some idiot like me can spin out something like this in two days that gets decent enough results, just imagine how this technology could be used by someone actually malicious. Are we going to be able to trust things that we read on the internet anymore? Are we going to be able to trust video? Audio? Text? Images?
Colonel: Raiden, you seem to think that our plan is one of censorship.
> Raiden: Are you telling me it's not!?
> Rose: You're being silly! What we propose to do is not to control content, but to create context.
> Raiden: Create context?
> [...]
> Colonel: Absolutely. Who else could wade through the sea of garbage you people produce, retrieve valuable truths and even interpret their meaning for later generations?
> Rose: That's what it means to create context.
> Raiden: I'll decide for myself what to believe and what to pass on!
> Colonel: But is that even your own idea?
> Rose: Or something Snake told you?
As I was writing all of this, Discord quite literally announced that they are making a new client feature with the ChatGPT API that allows them to automatically create context for your conversations. I literally can't make this up. The parallels and analogies are literally writing themselves at this point.
Who will be our patriots? This has been a question that's been rattling around throughout my skull for the last two weeks or more.
If you take a serious look at the Metal Gear series, you probably would find it dripping with allegory and other moments like this. The thing that comes to mind the most is the one of the most symbolically critical cutscenes from Metal Gear Rising: Revengance where Raiden is talking with the one of the bosses/enemy terrorists named Monsoon.
This game is also notable because it came out in that small sliver of time between modern gaming being a thing and the common definition of memes as what we know them as today didn't exist yet. In an anthropological sense, you can think about a meme as a viral idea, and that sense is being referred to below.
When Raiden is talking with Monsoon about war, violence, and justice, their conversation drifts to anthropology:
Monsoon: Yes, you aren't the only one to grow up on the killing fields. War is a cruel parent, but an effective teacher. Its final lesson is carved deep in my psyche: That this world, and all its people, are diseased. Free will is a myth. Religion is a joke. We are all pawns, controlled by something greater: Memes. The DNA of the soul. They shape our will. They are the culture -- they are everything we pass on. Expose someone to anger long enough, they will learn to hate. They become a carrier. Envy, greed, despair... All memes. All passed along.
When all these memes (both senses) build up and overwhelm us all, what happens? Where do people find actual truth when everything worth interacting with is drowned out.
Later in the game when Raiden fights the final boss, a United States Senator (this game is about as subtle as a nuclear bomb, it's great), they talk about the fallout of The Patriots being destroyed in the wake of the FOXALIVE virus (and the resumption of the uninterrupted flood of garbage onto the internet).
Senator Armstrong: All right, the truth then. You're right about one thing... I do need capital. And votes. Wanna know why?.. I have a dream.
> Raiden: What...?
> Senator Armstrong: That one day every person in this nation will control their OWN destiny. A land of the TRULY free, dammit! [Armstrong resumes fighting Raiden.] A nation of ACTION, not words, ruled by STRENGTH, not committee! [Armstrong grapples Raiden,rendering the cyborg mostly helpless.] Where the law changes to suit the individual, not the other way around. Where power and justice are back where they belong: in the hands of the people! [Armstrong and Raiden headbutt each other, but neither is harmed.] Where every man is free to think -- to act -- for himself! [Armstrong beats Raiden to punctuate every statement.] Fuck all these limp-dick lawyer and chicken-shit bureaucrats. Fuck this 24/7 Internet spew of trivia and celebrity bullshit. Fuck "American pride." Fuck the media! Fuck all of it! America is diseased. Rotten to the core. There's no saving it -- we need to pull it out by the roots. Wipe the slate clean. BURN IT DOWN! And from the ashes a new America will be born. Evolved, but untamed! The weak will be purged and the strongest will thrive -- free to live as they see fit, they'll make America great again!
To say that this game wears its heart on is sleeve is like trying to say that water makes things moist. Senator Armstrong's core thesis is that people need to be free to do what they want. However:
Colonel: You exercise your right to "freedom" and this is the result. All rhetoric to avoid conflict and protect each other from hurt. The untested truths spun by different interests continue to churn and accumulate in the sandbox of political correctness and value systems.
> Rose: Everyone withdraws into their own small gated community, afraid of a larger forum. They stay inside their little ponds, leaking whatever "truth" suits them into the growing cesspool of society at large.
> Colonel: The different cardinal truths neither clash nor mesh. No one is invalidated, but nobody is right.
> Rose: Not even natural selection can take place here. The world is being engulfed in "truth."
> Colonel: And this is the way the world ends. Not with a bang, but a whimper.
Communities that used to have public presences, online forums, wikis, all of that reduced to private, secluded, Discord servers. Spam has always been a problem that has required a lot of careful research and implementation because of how easy it is to do and how hard it is to only block the spammers, and not the legitimate users. And now new tools allow you to generate kilobytes of spam in tenths of pennies.
The things we experience become the memes we share with others. Expose someone to hate long enough, they'll hate too.
Colonel: That's the proof of your incompetence, right there. You lack the qualifications to exercise free will.
> Raiden: That's not true! I have the right--
> Rose: Does something like a "self" exist inside of you?
> Colonel: That which you call "self" serves as nothing more than a mask to cover your own being.
> Rose: In this era of ready-made 'truths', "self" is just something used to preserve those positive emotions that you occasionally feel...
> Colonel: Another possibility is that "self" is a concept you conveniently borrowed under the logic that it would endow you with some sense of strength.
It is very likely that we are living in an age of ready made truths, and this will all only get worse as these text transformer models get more and more easy to use, run on lower and lower and hardware, and become fast enough that they can be used in real time.
The traffic jam
This is the traffic jam. A traffic jam not made of cars, but ideas. Ideas and memes fed to people 24/7. God forbid what happens when somebody actually malicious gets their hands on these tools.
We're already rapidly approaching the point where you can't trust video and audio recordings of anything anymore. I've seen a new format of memes spread around in the last month or two. They use AI text to speech generation to show former and current US presidents in ridiculous scenarios such as Joe Biden, Donald Trump, Barack Obama and Chris Pratt playing Mario Party together:
Just imagine what a boon this could be for misinformation. Imagine a conspiracy, and with a few clicks of a mouse, create the evidence you need to spread it. Create the memes that you need in order to discredit your opposition. They'll spread like wildfire.
At this point, the genie is out of the bottle. Pandora's box is opened. We're going to have to learn to live with these diseases.
Next year is an election year. I can only imagine what kind of things we will end up being inflicted to on the Internet this next election cycle.
It's very likely that we're not going to be able to trust breaking news about political candidates very soon. It's also very likely that a lot of the articles that people read are going to look like those articles made by that joke of a website I made. Our world is being engulfed in relative truths based on assumptions. The common belief in an "objective reality" is crumbling.
One event happens. A million people witness it. A million separate headcanons of that become the reality for those million people. Some of them may be mutually understood by each other, but they are still a million separate interpretation that can all conflict in a million different ways. This is the way that that things always have been. We just don't like to think about this.
Above all, my biggest fear is that one of the biggest sources of liberation in my life is going to no longer be a source of liberation for anyone else. This is the technology that can truly kill the internet. Not with a bang, but with a whimper.
I couldn't figure out where to fit this in the article, but I suspect that a lot of the reason that so many companies are announcing AI products in recent days can boil down to two basic factors:
AI-based products are a perfect denial-of-service attack on product departments. They look cool as hell. They raise a lot of buzz. It only makes sense that people would want to raise that buzz and look cool as hell in order to get promoted.
The AI departments of most companies have not really published any products. The tech industry as a whole is going through economic downturns, and this is making companies look for places to cut the fat. I suspect that AI products are being introduced because it allows people to remain employed because their department is raising a lot of buzz.
This is truly a weapon to surpass Metal Gear. Now accessible through Bing and Google search. Now available for any kid with a dream and a credit card.
Facts and circumstances may have changed since publication. Please contact me before jumping to conclusions if something seems wrong or unclear.
Tags: philosophy, metalGear, futurism, sciFi, ChatGPT